HOME ABOUT US CONTACT US NEWSLETTER




March 2, 2001 - Cigna Settles Wrongful Death Suit

Cigna Corp., the second-largest health plan in North Texas, has settled a lawsuit filed by a Hurst man who alleged that his wife died after her doctor refused to hospitalize her because he was induced by her HMO to cut medical care costs.

The case was filed in 1999 by Chuck Barley, whose wife, Janet, died of a heart condition in September 1997. A nurse for 22 years, she had been a member of Healthsource North Texas, an HMO that was bought by Cigna in March 1997.

Court documents filed in the case show that Healthsource held back 10 percent of its fees to Consultants in Cardiology until the end of the year, and then awarded them as a "bonus" if doctors were able to keep costs down.

In addition, the contract between Healthsource and the cardiology practice contained a "gag" clause that prevented patients from finding out about the financial incentives for holding back medical services, the documents show.

The family alleged that Dr. Pugh did not hospitalize his wife in September 1997 even though she was showing symptoms of valvular heart disease. Instead, the doctor - named one of the city's top cardiologists in a survey of area doctors published recently by Fort Worth, Texas magazine - prescribed a drug called Betapace, which regulates the heartbeat.

The terms of the settlement are confidential and Cigna's spokeswoman, Tania Graves, declined to disclose details. However, the portion of the lawsuit against Fort Worth cardiologist Dr. Pugh and his practice, Consultants in Cardiology, is proceeding.

Wrongful death cases against HMOs are rare despite a 1997 Texas law that allowed patients to sue health plans for medical malpractice. One Fort Worth attorney who specializes in cases against managed care plans and helped with the 1997 law, said fewer than 20 such HMO lawsuits have been filed statewide.

In court documents, Cigna denied that the managed care agreement had any effect on Barley's treatment. Pugh testified in a deposition that the contract with Healthsource did not affect his professional judgment regarding her care.

If you or a loved one has been injured as a result of possible medical malpractice, call now at or CLICK HERE TO SUBMIT A SIMPLE CASE FORM. The initial consultation is free of charge, and if we agree to accept your case, we will work on a contingent fee basis, which means we get paid for our services only if there is a monetary award or recovery of funds. Don't delay! You may have a valid claim and be entitled to compensation for your injuries, but a lawsuit must be filed before the statute of limitations expires.

<< back



Bledsoe Law Office
408 Wood Avenue
Big Stone Gap, VA, 24219


Jonesville, VA
No. 2 Church Street*
Jonesville, Virginia 24263
(276) 346-3690


Bristol, TN
1619 Highway 11W
Bristol, Tennessee 37620
(423) 764-0322

See our Contact Us page for detailed map to each office